The City of Edinburgh Council's Transport and Environment Committee ('TEC') met on Thursday, 12th November; as ever, we've reviewed and rounded up all the cycling-adjacent decisions below.
It took flipping ages; you're more than welcome π€
π Meeting Page & Agenda | πΊ Webcast | PDFs: Β π Full Agenda Reports Pack | πΌ Business Bulletin | π Work Programme | π£ Deputations | π Motions & Amendments
π Business Bulletin [PDF] Β»
The Business Bulletin is home to less significant items that don't warrant a full report, or further updates on more significant past reports.
πΊ Discussion from 2h 18m 11s
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Covered briefly, Cllr Osler asked whether the review of loading also included Leith Walk and Elm Row. Officers answered that these main thoroughfares are 'constantly' under review but that updates coming back regarding side street loading will be sure to cover these roads also.
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Also covered fairly briefly - a report comes to committee in January, including close working with Lothian Buses and Edinburgh Trams on resilience planning.
πΊ Discussion from 2h 15m 22s
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Cllr Lang followed up on a previously given timeframe for communicating the Road Condition Index results for this year, along with the road investment programme, to be made more accessible to the public.
Officers confirmed that these items will be on the Council's website before then end of the year - the three-year programme for improvements β with dates more 'precise' in the first year and subsequent years less so because of further assessment needed nearer the time, as well as budget decisions each year affecting the programme.
πΊ Webcast from 2h 33m 17s
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Regarding the update on Powderhall, Cllr Booth asked: "There's a letter at the back of the business bulletin from the Cabinet Secretary that effectively says that despite the SNP manifesto commitment, they effectively seem to be washing their hands... so I wonder if we could get an update from officers - what are the next steps... given the Scottish Government don't seem to be that interested in supporting it, what's the way forward?
Head of Transport, Strategy and Partnerships Deborah Paton responded:
"Essentially, we are doing an ongoing process at the minute with Network Rail around the condition of the route, and looking at structures and trying to understand liabilities before we then make a decision whether we do want to take on that land ownership liability for an active travel route - so that is the ongoing process. Those processes do take time, and thatβs the process that weβre currently in, so certainly from our perspective there is no hold up - weβre just going through that process, and then weβll have to reach that decision point as to whether it is something that the Council wants to take on; because there could be substantial cost."
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
In response to a question from Cllr Booth on temporary repair or replacement, an officer from the Bridges & Structures team weighed in. Officers and 'subject matter experts' from consulting companies have stated that the nature of the bridge defect means temporary repairs are "unlikely to be feasible".
There are also utilities crossing the span that are a blocker to other options; a CityFibre internet cable and Scottish Power cabling are carried across the bridge, and are embedded within the structure so cannot be practically freed without extensive works.
As far as a drop-in temporary bridge, by the time the CityFibre and Scottish Power cables are redirected in order to remove the old bridge and a temporary bridge is commissioned, the timelines involved mean that we'd be close to the estimated implementation date that has been mooted (early 2028) for a full and permanent replacement anyway.
When asked about whether a council budget decision to address the issues would be enough to proceed - i.e. no further report to committee needed, assumedly to speed things along - Executive Director of Place Gareth Barlow responded that a budget decision at full council would be sufficient, following this by saying "The investment report that comes to this committee that sets out, across all the strands of transport infrastructure... I appreciate the point around is this a parks bridge, is this a transport bridge? I'm going to get myself in trouble with some colleagues by saying it is definitely going to be a transport bridge going forward. But we need to resource that department to do this."
Regarding the wider issue of bridge maintenance apparent from elsewhere in the city with the closure of the Kinauld Tanworks footbridge on the Water of Leith, as well as this bridge in St Mark's park, Mr Barwell added: "I do have to say - this is obviously a very important issue to that community. From memory this is about the fourth or fifth motion about dealing with bridges across our network. Unfortunately, that recognises the fact that we inherited lots of bridges, formerly on old railway infrastructure, and haven't had an asset management strategy in place to manage them - I think the overall strategy, we'll fix that."
Cllr McNeese Mechan asked "whether the council is responsible for maintaining those private company cables or should we be looking to them to put funds in to ensure their business is continuing unhindered." The answer from officers was that public utility companies are responsible for their own utilities, but there are statutory processes in place that result in the council needing to pay, albeit at a discounted rate, to have those moved where it requires them to be redirected due to other works. The officer responding went on to clarify that there is design work required from the utilities involved to refine their proposed diversions, which is an ongoing conversation as to how it would be accomplished and whether it might require a separate structure.
The Administration accepted the SNP [PDF, page 3] and Liberal Democrat [PDF, page 4] addenda, along with the offered paragraph 5 of the Green amendment [PDF, page 5] after Cllr Booth offered that much of the Green position was covered by the other positions.
π Report [PDF] Β»
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Councillors at committee expressed sympathy with the difficulties in running a business on a main road brought by the petitioner of this item, but were resolute that as per the deputation from Edinburgh Users Group, Spokes and others, improvements to bus priority has to be made to ensure buses remain an attractive and congestion-beating alternative to driving in the city.
The Administration position [PDF, page 6] also accepted point 4 from the Green Amendment [PDF, page 7] to refer the petitioner's views to the relevant traffic orders team for consideration as part of the Experimental Traffic Regulation Order ('ETRO') process, and this was voted through defeating a request from the Conservative group for a further report.
As such, the 7-7-7 trial will continue, with no changes desired β especially at such an early stage.
π Report [PDF] Β»
π€ Petitioner: Verbal Deputation and questions with Kirkliston residents Β»
πΊ Discussion & Voting from 2h 09m 21s
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Councillors called for swift action, following a thorough and well-evidenced petition from residents - not only on a site visit but on interventions to cull speeding for traffic exiting the village and creating safety issues. The Administration moved its own position [PDF, page 8] accepting the Green amendment [PDF, page 9] in full, which was agreed with no counter-positions.
For item 7.3 Petition for Consideration - Broomhall Road, Road Calming Measures [PDF], this was moved with the Administration position calling for any potential interventions to take account of adjacent long-running roadworks that may be causing some of the issues.
A Green amendment [PDF, page 11] calling for a review of how roadworks disruption is planned for regarding diversions and traffic calming in adjacent streets to anticipate these kinds of issues in future works was seen as one report too many, challenged by both Conservative Cllr Mowat and Convener Cllr Jenkinson as too great a demand on Officer time writing endless reports for committee rather than work implementing changes. Which is a shame, because of course if you shelve a report like this to focus Officer time on responding to every locality that pops up and says they need traffic calming, you miss out on heading off those requests by enabling systemic change to avoid them in the first place.
The Administration amendment [PDF, page 10] passed.
π Report [PDF] Β»
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
As stated in our look ahead at the TEC agenda;
This significant report brings together a number of city centre projects, lists them along with their status (main report PDF, page 6 onwards), and also proposes a way forward specifically for the stalled George St project.
The recommended design for George Street can be seen on page 3 of the appendix [PDF].
Discussions centred around George Street (it's worth reading through the report to understand just how many other schemes were also covered), and questions to Officers covered a number of key areas for the long-running saga of delivering a 'pedestrianised' George St:
The City Centre West to East Link runs from Roseburn in the West to Picardy Place in the East, but is a traffic void between the Charlotte Square and St Andrews Square portion of the route.
Access during build: It was confirmed (again, having been mooted previously at this committee and agreed in prior discussions) that Council Officers would work with contractors delivering the project to ensure cycle access along the length of George St during construction works;
Temporary uses: Cllr Cuthbert asked about report paragraph 4.15, which talks about diverting the primary cycle route in the case of a major incident in the city centre to use George St as a diversionary route for buses, learning from the resilience issues around the fire on Princes St in the summer. He went on to ask whether George street will still be used for public festival space, pop-up venues as it has been annually for some years. Executive Director of Place Gareth Barwell answered:
"...Future use of George Street for longer term β if you like β "occupations", is something that... I find quite hard to see going forward, because we're also acknowledging as a city that George Street is a very important relief road for us. That principally is what's determined the reduced need for HVM [Hostile Vehicle Mitigation], and the change in the surface in which colleagues have set out is why the cost of this project comes down substantially. So we'll have a bit of work to do around things like Edinburgh's Christmas, which is a contract that we own and making sure we use our space. But again, that's my job to join up all these different departments and make sure that the plan and the use for George Street fulfils its purpose in the transport network."
π So potentially, in 2031, cycle users will finally be able to ride the full, completed City Centre West to East Link a mere seven years after its opening ceremony in early 2024.
Nearly all parties were concerned with the removal of trees from the designs, which along with changes to the carriageway material and scaled down hostile vehicle mitigation implementation had been 'value engineered' out - as well as mentioned by Officers as having been 'contentious' with some heritage stakeholders (and folk think the evil cycling lobby is weird... who hates trees?)
Officers confirmed that the costs for trees in the design is around Β£350k for materials and Β£500k or so for associated excavation and implementation works, and could fairly easily be added back in. Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems ('SUDs') were retained in these designs already, and trees will complement these but also provided much needed shade and canopy in a warming climate.
Conservative Cllr Mowat queried the costs of Β£19.95m for George St and Β£13.75m investment to Princes St, when Visitor Levy funds for the city centre at full council were agreed at Β£31.75m, asking where the additional funding will come from.
Executive Director of Place Gareth Barwell stated that Officers are confident the costs are realistic, and that if budget measures are approved there will be a further Β£10m coming from elsewhere in the Council's reserves which together with 'tourist tax' funds creates a "robust project budget" for Princes St and George St.
In summing up, the Convener said:
"Committee has taken previous decisions on George Street, and yet we're here again, making another one. What I'm hopeful for today is that we as a committee take a decision, not just on George Street but on the other city centre public realm projects within the overall programme, which puts us very much in the delivery phase.
"We can agree on elements of the design... but I think what we need to do is provide some clarity and some certainty to the residents and the businesses of George Street and the city centre of what our plan is going forward, how we're going to fund it and when we're going to deliver it." β Transport Convener Cllr Stephen Jenkinson
Amendments from other groups ranged from trying to posit that there wasn't any money for some schemes and not enough money for others (Conservatives [PDF, page 22], naturally later outvoted 9-2), to by and large agreeing the proposals as long as the George St scheme re-included street trees (SNP [PDF, page 20], Green [PDF, page 21]) and also pushing for action on a permanent change to the Cowgate (SNP).
To reach consensus, the Greens withdrew their amendment to support the SNP, provided a verbal adjustment was made to the SNP amendment to ensure that access for cycling along George Street would be preserved during construction works. This was agreed by committee 9 votes to 2.
This is a landmark moment for a major piece of cycle infrastructure in the city - as well as for numerous other city centre projects included in the approved report.
π° National Coverage: article at The BBC Β»
π Report [PDF] Β»
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
This second of the three major reports to TEC this cycle; it's quite hard to keep track of the various overlapping strategies and acronyms, but as quoted in last week's info:
The City Mobility Plan 2021-2030 replaces Edinburghβs Local Transport Strategy 2014-2019.
It has been prepared alongside the City Plan 2030 to help Edinburgh connect through a safer and more inclusive carbon neutral transport system - delivering a healthier, thriving, fairer and compact capital city and a higher quality of life for all residents.
...It will help people make greener choices about how they move around the city, through improving walking, wheeling and cycling options and creating better links to public transport.
Projects agreed in the previous item β George St et al β all refer to the CMP's overarching strategy when considering transport impact, and the projects that deliver it are listed, scored, funded and green-lit through the CMP's 'Capital Investment Programme'. The CMP itself is reviewed every two years, which is where this item lines up; the investment programme (next item) is reviewed annually.
As you might expect from such a wide-ranging report, questions were all over the place, but included:
Cllr Booth asked about updates to the published version of CMP suggesting that HGV and LGV (van) vehicles have reduced in volume, and asked whether this seem accurate; Officers do believe this is credible, with changes in the city like industrial sites given over to housing, and that changes were also consistent across geographically dispersed counting sites;
Cllr Cuthbert asked about the bypass, stating that it is only mentioned four times in the City Mobility Plan; and pointed out that the remit of committee is to hold a strategic overview of all transport in the City. He referenced an ongoing incident at the time of the meeting which had closed both sides of the bypass, and pointed out the the resulting traffic 'carnage'.
Officers responded that strategic transport links are a part of the CMP, but the council don't really have control over what happens on the bypass (being only responsible for the section from Hermiston Gait to the Airport, otherwise the road is under the control of BEAR Scotland on behalf of the Scottish Government). Collaborative work on bus priority for key transport corridors in the south is underway with neighbouring councils. Gareth Barwell weighed in to say there should absolutely be resilience plans in place for when something does happen on the bypass to deal with the displaced traffic, which can have a varied geographic impact depending on where incidents occur;
Cllr Mowat asked about the aims to install four hundred dropped kerbs per year and asked about the number being installed - which Officers explained has been recently provided in response to questions at full council and in other reports, but has to be drawn together as there are different teams and programmes that install new dropped kerbs. In response, Cllr Mowat quite fairly pointed out a gathering together of that data into one place such as the CMP KPIs would prevent the requirement for additional questions;
Cllr Lang stated support for reducing the number of KPIs and asked if twenty-six was still too many. Officers believe 26 is a manageable number, and mentioned that Edinburgh is unusual in its biennial review of the CMP and KPIs - but that it's a good thing to keep reviewing;
Cllr Gardiner asked a question addressing the spread of count locations, particularly in South Edinburgh. It was great to hear from Officers, who are already confident in the robustness of the data, that a larger suite of counts has been recorded in 2025, so in future the data set will be wider for review (but these points weren't counted in 2019, so aren't yet included in the comparison);
Cllr Martinico asked about KPIs being removed due to a methodology that wasn't working, and asked whether it be possible to change methodology against a KPI rather than get rid of the indicator? altogether - especially as some KPIs were already changing measurements like time periods. Officers response was that as part of the process they have tried to consolidate KPIs where possible, and are focused on outcomes rather than outputs - but trying to strike a balance and are happy to hear from Councillors further;
Cllr Booth quoted stats from TomTom on Edinburgh as the UK's second most congested city, and asked how that lines up with a Council-reviewed 17% reduction in traffic volumes? Officers responded that traffic volume (as measured at 17% lower) is only one possible factor in congestion, but not the only one - road layout, obstructions such as parking or loading, timing of signals - many things feed in;
Cllr Mowat leapt on the mention of road space reallocation in this response to posit that by reducing road space for private traffic we potentially increase congestion. Officers saw this as "not completely reasonable" as data is showing modal shift at, for example, CCWEL and Leith Connections project routes, with people changing how they make their journeys and as a result seeing traffic volumes go down. In an additional example from adjacent to CCWEL, traffic volume has decreased significantly at the junction of Roseburn Street, but queue lengths have remained consistent, because there is now a pedestrian signal phase across all arms of the junction, and prioritisation of traffic passage is given to the A8 to the detriment of cars using Roseburn Street, in order to give the most benefit to users of public transport on the corridor - so there is complexity in every aspect that can't be reduced down to a single factor β in this case it was perceived that the CCWEL project worsened traffic on Roseburn Street, when data shows it lowered it.
Cllr Booth asked if it was premature to pause policies on a Workplace Parking Levy and Congestion Charging, particularly given recent comments from First Minister John Swinney in support of the latter. Officers responded that they have no current instruction from Councillors for a parking levy (after it was ruled out at a previous TEC vote), and don't have powers to enforce the latter until further legislative work from the Scottish Government - but that in future it would be within committee's gift to reintroduce either policy were things to change;
The Administration moved the report and Officer recommendations; in seconding, Cllr Ruth Elliot mentioned speaking to Edinburgh Critical Mass protestors outside the City Chambers, pointing out that it was great to see people who want this plan enacted.
The Green and Conservative groups moved their own amendments; Convener Cllr Jenkinson moved the report, not accepting the Green amendment [PDF, page 23] but accepting point 1.6 of the Conservative amendment [PDF, page 25] as an addendum; this position subsequently won out over the Green 6 votes to 5.
This is particularly unfortunate as to some of the KPIs involved for walking and cycling, which the Green amendment looked to fix; as reader Alastair kindly provided to us in the days following the meeting:
You may have seen this, but in the KPIs for CMP, there's a change.
In the old ones:
- Item 22 was to reduce pedestrian serious injuries by 40%, had gone from 55.4 to 44.8, rated 'green'
- Item 23 was to reduce cycling serious injuries by 30%, had gone from 33.6 to 35.8, rated green
In the new ones, these have been combined/replaced with 'continue trend of reducing injuries to cyclists & pedestrians', and the current state is 'green' based on totalling the numbers above.
So (1) this looks like a much less ambitious target and (2) by redefining the targets, 'cycling injuries' which are increasing, are suddenly 'green'.
Put well by Spokes, in their written deputation [PDF, page 31] on these and other KPIs set for removal:
"Ultimately, the purpose of monitoring is to provide an honest assessment of progress, including whereobjectives are not being met. Removing inconvenient or challenging indicators risks weakening the Plan's accountability and undermining public confidence in its delivery. Where existing measures are no longer appropriate, they should be updated or replaced with more effective indicators, rather than simply discontinued."
π Report [PDF] Β»
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
This item, as described in last week's roundup, is:
Less theoretical than the CMP itself, this is the annual update to how the CMP's 'active and sustainable' projects are being prioritised. They're scored against a number of criteria (Appendix 5B) and ranked to set out how their delivery will be scheduled, along with how they'll be funded - mainly externally.
This item was reached following the 5pm cut-off, at which point the committee goes 'formal' with much less in the way of discussion and contributions.
The Administration rejected the Conservative amendment [PDF, page 27], and accepted point b) of the Green amendment [PDF, page 26] as an addendum to the report, a position which won out after a couple of rounds of weary voting. Good news for residents of Royal Park Terrace and Spring Gardens who gave deputation, as this point b) instructed:
"That in respect of the Royal Park Terrace / Spring Gardens request for a modal filter, that officers, when modelling traffic for the City Centre Transformation, include in their modelling the impact of a modal filter at this location, and report their findings to committee within three cycles on potential ways forward."
None of these items were discussed at committee, as they are optional and dependent on whether Councillors wish to ask questions about them or amend them.
π Read our background on these items from last week Β»
π Report PDF
This passed formally, including the Green amendment [PDF, page 28] in full.
π Report PDF - not discussed at committee.
π Report PDF - delayed until January.
This item was moved formally by the Administration, with an interjection from Liberal Democrat councillors moving for a continuance on the grounds of having had no chance to question officers on the report; after a brief adjournment to discuss, the committee had agreed to discuss ahead of items for decision in January's meeting.
π Motion [PDF] Β»
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
Following a contribution from Officers that the Β£25k cost of replacing this footbridge can be found within existing budgets and will go ahead, this motion was withdrawn.
π Motion [PDF]
π¬ Discussion & Voting from 5h 45m 29s
π Read our background on this item from last week Β»
The counter-position Green amendment [PDF, page 32] to this (arguably silly) motion was rejected by the Conservative group, who were then roundly outvoted 9-2 by the rest of the Transport & Environment Young Team, closing out the day's business.
π The Transport & Enviroment Committee will next meet in January of next year, and we'll have a round-up in our subsequent issues.